America's Insurance Crisis and Its Impact on Housing

In partnership with

Start learning AI in 2025

Everyone talks about AI, but no one has the time to learn it. So, we found the easiest way to learn AI in as little time as possible: The Rundown AI.

It's a free AI newsletter that keeps you up-to-date on the latest AI news, and teaches you how to apply it in just 5 minutes a day.

Plus, complete the quiz after signing up and they’ll recommend the best AI tools, guides, and courses – tailored to your needs.

Sign up to start learning.

If you’ve been keeping an eye on the news lately, you’ve likely noticed that severe weather is becoming increasingly destructive. Storms are wreaking havoc, even in areas once thought to be relatively safe. As a result, the insurance industry is paying a hefty price, losing billions to natural catastrophes year after year.

In 2023, 18 of the top 20 insurance providers in the U.S. had loss ratios over 100%. This means they are paying out more in claims than they’re collecting in premiums. Despite home insurance prices increasing by 35% since 2021, insurers are still raising premiums, leaving many homeowners in a difficult position. But what does this mean for America’s already unstable housing market? Let's dive deeper into the crisis.

The Root of the Problem: How Insurers Make Money

To understand why premiums are soaring, we first need to understand how insurance companies work. The core principle is the law of large numbers. Essentially, insurers rely on the fact that they can predict the overall cost of claims by spreading the risk across a large number of policies.

For example, let’s imagine an insurer covers 60 houses and charges $1 per year per house. Based on statistical averages, one house will suffer catastrophic damage, five will experience severe damage, and ten will need minor repairs. If the insurer collects $60 in premiums but has to pay out $45 in claims, they make a profit of $15. But what happens when weather patterns become more extreme?

The New Reality of Extreme Weather

Today, weather is anything but average. Extreme events are happening more frequently, and the cost of claims is increasing rapidly. If the same 60 houses now experience two catastrophic damages, eight severe ones, and 15 needing minor repairs, the insurer is looking at $75 in losses, 25% higher than the premiums collected. This is where the problem begins.

Because extreme weather is occurring more often, insurers are forced to raise premiums to cover these unpredictable costs. However, reinsurers (the insurance companies that help insurers cover large-scale losses) are also feeling the strain. To avoid losses, reinsurers are either raising premiums or exiting certain markets altogether. This, in turn, forces primary insurers to do the same.

The Nationwide Impact

You might think this is just an issue for states with extreme weather, like California and Florida. However, home insurance premiums are rising across the entire U.S. Louisiana, Maine, Michigan, and Utah are all seeing significant increases, even though they are not traditionally considered high-risk areas. For example, in Maine, sea levels are rising, increasing the risk of coastal storms. In Michigan, convection storms (hail, floods, and hurricane-force winds) are becoming more frequent.

The problem is compounded by inflation. Homes are more expensive to build, and the cost to repair them has skyrocketed. With insurers facing more risk and higher repair costs, it’s no surprise they are asking for higher premiums.

The Housing Market: A Lose-Lose Situation

This brings us to a critical issue: the housing market. Higher premiums are driving more and more Americans out of homeownership. In fact, a survey of housing providers revealed that 52% are considering decreasing or postponing investments due to rising insurance costs. This means fewer affordable homes are being built, and even families who already own homes may find themselves priced out due to unaffordable insurance hikes.

What’s even more concerning is the increasing number of Americans going without home insurance altogether. In 2024, 6.2 million Americans are uninsured, leaving their properties vulnerable to catastrophic damage.

Solutions: What Can Be Done?

So, how can we address this crisis?

1. Higher Premiums: Homeowners may be forced to pay higher premiums. This, however, is not an ideal solution for families, especially those with limited incomes.

2. Downsizing: Many people are opting for smaller homes, but this isn’t always feasible, especially when considering the difficulty of finding affordable insurance options.

3. Reducing Coverage: Some homeowners are choosing higher deductibles to reduce premiums, but this can leave them underinsured, risking financial ruin if disaster strikes.

4. Forgoing Insurance: This is the most dangerous option, but with millions uninsured, it’s becoming a real problem, especially for low-income families and people of color.

The Bigger Risk: Economic Consequences

The real danger lies in the broader economic impact. The value of uninsured properties in the U.S. is estimated at $1.6 trillion. If these properties are damaged or destroyed, the ripple effects could undermine banks, governments, and the housing market, leading to even more instability.

A New Approach to Housing

In the long term, solving this crisis will require a shift in how and where we build homes. It’s essential to stop constructing houses in high-risk areas. Yet, many Americans continue to ignore the risks, with population growth in high-risk states like Texas continuing despite increasing threats from natural disasters.

For now, homeowners must focus on preventive maintenance, such as reinforcing foundations and addressing weather-related vulnerabilities. This will help mitigate the effects of extreme weather and reduce the strain on insurance providers.

In conclusion, the rising cost of home insurance is a ticking time bomb for the housing market. If we do not address the root causes—extreme weather, inflation, and an unprepared housing market—homeownership will become an unattainable dream for many Americans. The time to act is now.